User Tools

Site Tools


field_methods:site_condition_assessment

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
field_methods:site_condition_assessment [2010/01/06 10:54]
jasonkarl
field_methods:site_condition_assessment [2013/02/21 10:35] (current)
jgillan
Line 1: Line 1:
-<​sup>​[[:​bug_reporting|Report a bug, broken link, or incorrect content]]</​sup>​+<​sup>​[[:​bug_reporting|Report a bug, broken link, or incorrect content]]</​sup>​[[http://​methods.landscapetoolbox.org|{{ field_methods:​methodsguide3.png?​220x120|}}]]
 ====== Site Condition Assessment ====== ====== Site Condition Assessment ======
- [[http://​www.rangelandmethods.org/​about/​get_involved|{{:​abstract_in_dev.gif|}}]]+<​HTML>​ 
 +<div style="​float:​ left; margin-right:​ 10px; margin-bottom:​ 2px;">​ 
 +<script type="​text/​javascript">​ 
 +digg_url = location.href;​ 
 +</​script>​ 
 +<script src="​http://​digg.com/​tools/​diggthis.js"​ type="​text/​javascript">​ 
 +</​script>​ 
 +</​div>​ 
 +</​HTML>​ 
 + 
 + [[http://​www.landscapetoolbox.org/​about/​get_involved|{{:​abstract_in_dev.gif|}}]]\\ 
 +contributed by Karen Colson and Jason Karl
  
 ===== Method Type ===== ===== Method Type =====
Line 10: Line 21:
  
 ===== Description and Uses ===== ===== Description and Uses =====
-Site condition ​assessment evaluates ​the condition of an area over time through repeated, subjective ​observations. This method is largely free-form - meaning that the attributes being observed can be defined in almost any way. As such, site condition assessment can be useful for assessing or monitoring a wide range of things like: presence or emergence of disturbed areas, impacts of off-road vehicles, invasive species, animal disturbance,​ and condition of fences or roads. The individual assessments can focus on one specific aspect of the site or activity, or a range of disturbances,​ actions, or characteristics. ​+Site condition ​assessments are simply subjective interpretations of the condition of a site at a particular point in time. These assessments are generally based on qualitative ​observations. Very large changes can sometimes be monitored using repeated assessments. This method is largely free-form - meaning that the attributes being observed can be defined in almost any way. As such, site condition assessment can be useful for assessing or monitoring a wide range of things like: presence or emergence of disturbed areas, impacts of off-road vehicles, invasive species, animal disturbance,​ and condition of fences or roads. The individual assessments can focus on one specific aspect of the site or activity, or a range of disturbances,​ actions, or characteristics. ​
 \\ \\ \\ \\
 Elzinga et al. (2001) provide a number of suggestions to improve the reliability of site condition assessments:​ Elzinga et al. (2001) provide a number of suggestions to improve the reliability of site condition assessments:​
Line 17: Line 28:
   - Site condition assessments should always be done using a standard field form defined according to the management objective. Such forms can contain definitions or examples of what should be observed and recorded and can prompt the recorded to pay attention to certain things.   - Site condition assessments should always be done using a standard field form defined according to the management objective. Such forms can contain definitions or examples of what should be observed and recorded and can prompt the recorded to pay attention to certain things.
   - given the large degree of variability between observers, site condition assessment is more effective at detecting new disturbances than it is in detecting change in existing disturbed areas. ​   - given the large degree of variability between observers, site condition assessment is more effective at detecting new disturbances than it is in detecting change in existing disturbed areas. ​
 +The most important factor affecting the quality of an assessment is the availability of accurate reference information for the particular soil and climate conditions (i.e. ecological site).
  
 ===== Advantages and Limitations ===== ===== Advantages and Limitations =====
 The biggest advantage to site condition assessment is that it is fast and easy to implement. It can work for areas and situations where assessment and/or monitoring objectives are well defined and tied to readily identifiable attributes that show a large degree of change in response to natural or management processes. The biggest advantage to site condition assessment is that it is fast and easy to implement. It can work for areas and situations where assessment and/or monitoring objectives are well defined and tied to readily identifiable attributes that show a large degree of change in response to natural or management processes.
 \\ \\ \\ \\
-The obvious limitation of this method is that it is very subjective and generally does not involve quantitative measurements. Also, the degree of change that must take place before it can be detected using site condition assessment can be very large. For these reasons, this method can be prone to bias, and it is also not possible to characterize uncertainty or express confidence in inferences drawn from site condition assessment data.+The obvious limitation of this method is that it is very subjective and generally does not involve quantitative measurements. Also, the degree of change that must take place before it can be detected using site condition assessment can be very large. For these reasons, this method can be prone to bias, and it is also not possible to characterize uncertainty or express confidence in inferences drawn from site condition assessment data. It also lacks a standard reference, such as the ecological site-specific reference sheets used with “Interpreting Indicators of Rangeland Health.”
  
 ===== Manuals/​Instructions ===== ===== Manuals/​Instructions =====
-  * Elzinga et al. (2001) Measuring and Monitoring Plant Populations.+  * Elzinga et al. (2001) Measuring and Monitoring Plant Populations: [[http://​www.blm.gov/​nstc/​library/​pdf/​MeasAndMon.pdf]]
  
 ===== Technical and Application References ===== ===== Technical and Application References =====
Line 30: Line 42:
  
 ===== Similar Approaches ===== ===== Similar Approaches =====
-Site condition assessment ​is a very flexible and loosely-defined assessment and monitoring method. While it is not as rigorous as some of the other condition ​measures, it is similar in nature to techniques and protocols like [[field_methods:​rangeland_health_assessment|]] and [[field_methods:​pasture_condition_scoring|]].+The term “Site condition assessment” applies to any single or repeated set of observations ​of the condition ​of a plot. 
 +[[field_methods:​rangeland_health_assessment_i.e._indicators_of_rangeland_health|Interpreting Indicators of Rangeland Health]] and [[field_methods:​pasture_condition_scoring|Pasture Condition Scoring]] were developed to standardize the assessment process.
  
 ===== Additional Information ===== ===== Additional Information =====
Line 74: Line 87:
     </​table>​     </​table>​
 </​html>​ </​html>​
 +
 +{{tag> qualitative field condition indicator}}
  
 ===== Discussion/​Comments ===== ===== Discussion/​Comments =====
-<​sub>​**You must have an account and be logged in to post or reply to the discussion topics below. [[http://abstracts.rangelandmethods.org/​doku.php/​Home?​do=login&​sectok=db3676cff5bcd873b609b4e582432d73|Click here]] to login or register for the site.**</​sub>​ +<​sub>​**You must have an account and be logged in to post or reply to the discussion topics below. [[http://wiki.landscapetoolbox.org/​doku.php/​Home?​do=login&​sectok=db3676cff5bcd873b609b4e582432d73|Click here]] to login or register for the site.**</​sub>​ 
-~~DISCUSSION| ~~+ 
field_methods/site_condition_assessment.1262800494.txt.gz · Last modified: 2012/02/22 13:28 (external edit)